Skip to content
Anonymous preview

Reactance adds to resistance arithmetically, not in quadratureActive cluster

Read the students' words first, then decide whether this grouping represents one shared misconception.

Spread
28%
11 of 40 answers
Average loss
4.5
marks lost per affected answer
Affected students
11
in this misconception cluster

Verbatim evidence

Every answer in this cluster, with the phrase that triggered the grouping highlighted

11 answers
  • EEE/022/0133P.G.6/1086%
    X_L = 2πfL = 2(3.142)(50)(0.1) = 31.42 Ω. Z = R + X_L = 30 + 31.42 = 61.42 Ω. I = 240/61.42 = 3.91 A. φ = tan⁻¹(31.42/30) = 46.3°.
  • EEE/022/0135Q.H.6/1096%
    Reactance = 31.4 Ω, resistance = 30 Ω, so total impedance = 61.4 Ω. I = 240/61.4 = 3.9 A. The angle is 46°.
  • EEE/022/0137R.J.5/1079%
    In a series circuit things add up, so Z = 30 + 31.4 = 61.4 Ω. Current = 3.91 A. Phase angle 46 degrees.
  • EEE/022/0139S.L.5/1089%
    X_L = 31.42 Ω. Adding this to R gives 61.42 Ω as the impedance, so the current is 240 ÷ 61.42 = 3.9 A lagging.
  • EEE/022/0141T.P.6/1072%
    X_L = 2πfL = 2(3.142)(50)(0.1) = 31.42 Ω. Z = R + X_L = 30 + 31.42 = 61.42 Ω. I = 240/61.42 = 3.91 A. φ = tan⁻¹(31.42/30) = 46.3°.
  • EEE/022/0143U.V.6/1082%
    Reactance = 31.4 Ω, resistance = 30 Ω, so total impedance = 61.4 Ω. I = 240/61.4 = 3.9 A. The angle is 46°.
  • EEE/022/0145V.W.5/1092%
    In a series circuit things add up, so Z = 30 + 31.4 = 61.4 Ω. Current = 3.91 A. Phase angle 46 degrees.
  • EEE/022/0147W.Y.6/1075%
    X_L = 31.42 Ω. Adding this to R gives 61.42 Ω as the impedance, so the current is 240 ÷ 61.42 = 3.9 A lagging.
  • EEE/022/0149X.Z.5/1085%
    X_L = 2πfL = 2(3.142)(50)(0.1) = 31.42 Ω. Z = R + X_L = 30 + 31.42 = 61.42 Ω. I = 240/61.42 = 3.91 A. φ = tan⁻¹(31.42/30) = 46.3°.
  • EEE/022/0151Y.A.6/1095%
    Reactance = 31.4 Ω, resistance = 30 Ω, so total impedance = 61.4 Ω. I = 240/61.4 = 3.9 A. The angle is 46°.
  • EEE/022/0153Z.B.5/1078%
    In a series circuit things add up, so Z = 30 + 31.4 = 61.4 Ω. Current = 3.91 A. Phase angle 46 degrees.
Use the original responses—not the generated label—to decide whether this cluster is coherent.
Why these responses belong togetherReview the model's rationale and the recurring error signatures.

These students know reactance belongs in the answer and put it there. They carry over scalar addition from resistor networks, where series quantities genuinely do sum directly.

Evidence signatures

  • believes reactance adds arithmetically to resistance rather than in quadrature
  • believes series AC quantities sum directly the way series resistances do

Affected students

11 in this cluster

  • 0133
  • 0135
  • 0137
  • 0139
  • 0141
  • 0143
  • 0145
  • 0147
  • 0149
  • 0151
  • 0153

Demo class — initials and invented IDs only.

Downstream topics at risk

Severity 5 of 5

  • Phasor diagrams
  • Complex power and the power triangle
  • Three-phase load balancing
  • Transmission line modelling
Damage score 55 = severity 5 × 11 students

Edit cluster

Rename, merge, split, or reject this grouping.