Skip to content
Anonymous preview

Impedance and resistance are the same quantity

A five-minute sample lesson for the 15 students who hold this belief.

Copy or download this sample lesson and its affected-student roster.

Micro-lesson: The belief, said plainly

Start with the objective, then use the explanation and worked example.

~5 min

Objective

Recognise and correct the misconception before answering the diagnostic.

01Explanation

You treated Z and R as the same quantity — that the opposition in this circuit is 30 Ω, and the inductor is along for the ride.

02Why it is a reasonable thing to believe

In every DC circuit you have solved, opposition to current was one number with one name. An inductor in a DC steady state really does behave like a piece of wire. If your mental model of an inductor was built in DC, it is not obviously wrong here — it is out of date.

03Worked example

An inductor opposes a *change* in current, and in a 50 Hz supply the current changes direction a hundred times a second. That opposition has a size: X_L = 2πfL = 31.4 Ω — larger, in this circuit, than the resistance itself. Ignoring it does not cause a small error. It gives 8 A instead of 5.5 A: a 45% overestimate of the current the circuit actually draws.

04The one-line correction

R opposes current. X_L opposes change in current. Z is what you get when you combine them, and only Z belongs in I = V/Z.

Two-question diagnostic

A student holding this belief fails these. A student who has corrected it passes.

  1. The same RL circuit is connected first to a 240 V DC supply, then to a 240 V, 50 Hz AC supply. Will the steady current be the same in both cases? Answer yes or no and give the reason.

    Reveal diagnostic responses
    Still holds the belief

    Yes, the same — because they see one opposition, R, unchanged by the supply type.

    Has corrected it

    No: 8 A on DC, 5.5 A on AC, because X_L is zero at DC and 31.4 Ω at 50 Hz.

  2. The supply frequency is doubled to 100 Hz, everything else unchanged. Does the current increase, decrease, or stay the same?

    Reveal diagnostic responses
    Still holds the belief

    Stays the same — frequency has no route into the answer if opposition is just R.

    Has corrected it

    Decreases, because X_L doubles to 62.8 Ω, raising Z and so lowering I.

Roster attached — the finding converts straight into an action.

Back to the evidence